C.T. Powell in his book ‘Seeing is Believing’ reports on an interchange between a high school teacher and one of her students about evidence for the existence of God. The teacher had challenged the students to provide one piece of tangible evidence and, because no-one could, she said: ‘Then our logical conclusion is that God doesn’t exist.’ But one girl challenged her on this by saying: “Just because we can’t see something doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. We could do brain surgery and investigate the parts of your brain and we could do a CAT scan and see the brain patterns in your head. But we couldn’t prove that you’ve had a single thought today. Does that mean that you haven’t thought anything today?
Evidence comes in many forms; you don’t always have to see to believe. There are some things you just know are true.
-
Recent Posts
Archives
- January 2021
- December 2020
- November 2020
- November 2018
- August 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- November 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
- September 2016
- April 2016
- March 2016
- February 2016
- January 2016
- December 2015
- November 2015
- October 2015
- September 2015
- August 2015
- July 2015
- June 2015
- May 2015
- April 2015
- March 2015
- February 2015
- January 2015
- December 2014
- November 2014
- October 2014
- September 2014
- August 2014
- July 2014
- June 2014
- May 2014
- April 2014
- March 2014
- February 2014
- January 2014
- December 2013
- November 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- August 2013
- July 2013
- June 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
Categories
- Abundant life
- Acceptance
- Accepting
- Access to God
- Accidents
- Accomplishments
- accountability
- Achievement
- Actions
- Activism
- Acts of Kindness
- Adopted child
- Advent
- Adventure
- Advocate
- Affirmation
- Affluence
- Afterlife
- Age
- Agnosticism
- Alistair McGrath
- Ambition
- Anchor
- Anger
- angry with God
- Animals
- Anxiety
- ANZAC Day
- Apathy
- Apology
- Appetites
- Applause
- Appreciation
- Armour of God
- Arrogance
- Artur Rubinstein
- asceticism
- Aspiration
- Assumptions
- Assurance
- Atheism
- Atlas
- Atom Bomb
- Attending Church
- Attitude
- Availability
- Awareness
- Babe Ruth
- Backsliding
- Bad Habits
- Bad luck
- Balance
- Balance life
- Beatitudes
- Beauty
- Believing
- Bethlehem
- Bible
- Big Bang
- Bigotry
- Bitterness
- Blessedness
- Blessings
- Blindness
- Body
- Body builders
- Bondage
- Boredom
- Brain
- Brevity of life
- Broken heart
- Burdens
- Busyness
- Called and Chosen
- Calmness
- Capacities
- career
- carelessness
- Cat
- Caution
- Certainty
- Character
- Charity
- Cheerfulness
- Childlike faith
- children
- Children of God
- Chines farmers
- Choices
- Christ
- Christian Courtesy
- Christianity
- Christlikeness
- Christmas
- Church
- Civilization
- Cleverness
- Coincidence
- Comfort Zone
- Common sense
- Communication
- Companionship
- Comparisons
- Compass
- Compassion
- Computer
- Conditioning
- Confession
- Confidence
- Conflict
- Conscience
- consequences
- consumerism
- Contemplation
- Contentment
- Contradictions
- Conversion
- Cornel university
- Cost
- Courage
- Covenant
- creation
- Cross
- Cruelty
- Curses
- Cynicism
- Danger
- Dare
- Death
- Death of God
- Deceit
- Deciding
- Decisions
- Defeated
- Defender
- Deferred gratification
- Deism
- Deliverance
- Demands
- Denial
- Depression
- Designer
- Desmond Tutu
- Despair
- Destruction
- Determination
- Devil
- Diets
- direction
- Disappointed
- Disatisfaction
- Discerning God's Will
- Discernment
- Discipleship
- Discouraged
- Disobedience
- Distraction
- Divine intelligence
- Divine Protection
- Dogma
- Doing what has to be done
- Don Bradman
- Don Quixote
- Double-mindedness
- Doubt
- Dreams
- Easter
- Embarrassment
- emotional stability
- emptiness
- Encouragement
- End of the World
- Endurance
- Enemy
- enjoyment
- Enrichment
- Environment
- Envy
- Epitaphs
- Escape
- Eternal life
- Eternity
- Evidence
- Evil
- Example
- Expectations
- Eyes to see
- facing our fears
- Facing the future
- Failure
- Faith
- Faithfulness
- fame
- Family
- Fatalism
- Fate
- Favourites
- Fear
- Feeling
- Feeling Indispensible
- Feelings
- Finding oneself
- Fingerprints of God
- Flashbacks
- Focusing
- Following the Crowd
- Food
- Foolishness
- Forbidden Fruit
- Forgetting
- Forgiveness
- Fred Culbertson
- Freedom
- Freedom from self
- Friends
- Fruits of the Spirit
- Fulfilment
- funerals
- Futility
- Future
- Gambling
- Gatekeepers
- Generosity
- Generous spirit
- Gentlemanly behaviour
- Gentleness
- Gift of God
- Giving
- God
- God in us
- God shaped holes
- God with us
- God's faithfulness
- God's love
- God's nature
- God's pleasure
- God's presence
- God's Will
- Going Nowhere
- Golden Rule
- Good deeds
- Good Name
- Good temper
- Goodness
- Gospel
- Grace
- Gratitude
- Great Endeavours
- Greatness
- Greed
- Grief
- Growth
- Guidance
- Guilt
- Half heartedness
- Happiness
- Hardened heart
- Hatred
- Healing
- Healthy life
- Heart
- Heart attack
- Heaven
- Heirs of God
- Hell
- Hiking
- Holy Communion
- Holy Spirit
- Hope
- hope and love
- Hope of Glory
- Hostility
- Human nature
- humility
- Hurting ourselves
- If
- Immortality
- Impartiality
- Imperfection
- important people
- Incarnation
- Indifference
- Individualism
- Indwelling Christ
- Inexpressible longings
- Influence
- Ingratitude
- Initiative
- Injustice
- inner peace
- inner yearning
- Inspiration
- Inspirational
- Insults
- Intelligence behind the Universe
- Intuitive understanding
- Investments
- Invitation
- Islamism
- Jesus
- Journey
- Joy
- Judgement
- Judgementalism
- Justice
- Kindness
- Kingdom of God
- Knowing God
- Knowledge
- Lack of understanding
- Laughter
- Law of Jungle
- Laws
- Legacies
- Legalism
- Leprosy
- Lies
- Life
- Life's journey
- Life's lessons
- Light
- Light of Life
- Listening
- Literary Criticism
- Living Life
- Living simply
- Loneliness
- Looking ahead
- Losers
- Lost
- love
- Love of Christ
- Love of the easy way
- Loving God
- Loving other people
- Loving your enemies
- Lucifer
- Luck
- Majority opinion
- Making the most of what you've got
- Manuscripts
- marriage
- Materialism
- Maturity
- Meaning in life
- Meaninglessness
- Memorials
- Memories
- Mercy
- mid life
- Miracles
- Misers
- Misery
- Mistakes
- Moderation
- Money
- Moods
- Moral and spiritual instruction
- Moral compass
- Mother's love
- Mother's words
- Motivation
- Mourning
- Moving on
- Muscles
- Music
- Music of life
- Mysteries of life
- Mystery
- Nativity
- Natural laws
- Negative thinking
- Neighbours
- Neurosis
- New Heart
- New Life
- New love
- New start
- Nobility
- Nuclear War
- Obedience
- Obituaries
- old age
- Opportunities
- Oppression
- Oscar Wilde
- Over-sensitivity
- Overcoming
- Pain
- Paradise
- Pardon
- Parental mistakes
- Passing the Peace
- Passions
- Patience
- Patriotism
- Peace
- Peace of mind
- Peaceful Sleep
- Peacemakers
- Perceiving
- perception
- Persecution
- Perseverance
- Persistence
- Personal Growth
- Perspective
- Phobialist.com
- Phobias
- pilgrimage
- Places of Worship
- Planet
- Popular opinion
- Positive Thoughts
- Possessions
- Possibilities
- potatoes
- Poverty
- Power
- Power for evil
- Power for good
- Power over People
- Prayer
- Preacher
- Prejudice
- Presence of Christ
- Pride
- Priming your pump
- Priorities
- Prisoners
- Privacy
- Privilege
- Prizes
- Promise
- Prophecy
- Providence
- Purification
- Purpose in life
- Putting first things first
- Quarrel
- quietness
- Raising Children
- re-evaluating life
- Reaping what you sow
- Reason
- Reconciliation
- Records
- References
- Reflecting
- Regeneration
- Regret
- Rejecting God
- relationships
- Relief
- Religion
- Religious Scam
- Remembering the past
- Remembrance
- Removing Obstacles
- Renewed Minds
- Repentance
- Reputation
- Resentment
- Resisting the Devil
- Respect
- responsibility
- Rest
- Restitution
- Restlessness
- Resurrection
- Retirement
- Return of Christ
- Returning to God
- Revealing God
- Revelation
- Revenge
- Reward
- Rice
- Richard Dawkins
- Riches
- Ridicule
- Righteousness
- risk takers
- Risking
- Robert Oppenheimer
- Romance
- Roses
- Rush
- Sacrifice
- Salt of the earth
- Salvation
- Satan
- satisfaction
- Saying sorry
- scar
- Scavengers
- Science and faith
- Scriptures
- Searching
- Second chance
- Second coming of Christ
- Security
- Seeing Jesus
- Seeing the best in people
- Seeing the possibilities
- Seeking and Finding
- Self assessment
- Self Deception
- Self Destruction
- Self Discipline
- Self giving
- Self Image
- Self respect
- Self-control
- Selfishness
- Selflessness
- selling our souls
- Senses
- Separation
- Sermons
- Servant leadership
- Service
- Seven Wonders of the World
- Shame
- Shrines
- Sight
- Silence
- Sin
- Sincerity
- Six degrees of separation
- Sleep
- Sleeplessness
- Soldiers
- Sorrow
- Soul
- Speaking the truth
- Speculation
- Spiritual blessing
- Spiritual blindness
- Spiritual comfort
- Spiritual Darkness
- Spiritual discernment
- Spiritual Energy
- Spiritual Furniture
- Spiritual growth
- Spiritual Immunity
- Spiritual Insight
- Spiritual Leaders
- Spiritual nourishment
- Spirituality
- Spirituality revolution
- Spite
- Spread of Gospel
- St Christopher
- Standards
- Starting afresh
- Stewardship
- Stickability
- Stillness
- Storms of life
- Stradivarius
- Strength
- Stress filled life
- Stubborness
- Stunted growth
- Submission to God's will
- Substitutes
- Substitution
- Success
- Suffering
- Suffering love
- Superficial judgements
- supportive community
- supreme being
- Survival of Fittest
- Sympathy and Support
- Synchronicity
- Taking self too seriously
- Taking stock
- Talking
- Target
- Temptation
- Tempted
- Terror
- Terrorism
- Terrorists
- Tested
- thankfulness
- The God Delusion
- Thoughtlessness
- Time management
- Touching God
- Touchstone
- Tourette's Syndrome
- Toxic assets
- Tranquility
- Transformation
- Transformed mind
- Treasure
- Treasure in Heaven
- Trials and testings
- tribulation and trouble
- Tried
- Triumphs
- Troubles
- True and False Religion
- True greatness
- Trust in God
- Trustworthiness
- Truth
- Truthfulness
- Unbelief
- Uncategorized
- Uncertainty of Life
- Unconditional Love
- understanding
- Unfaithfulness
- unforgiveness
- Unhappiness
- Uniqueness
- Uniqueness of Christianity
- Universe
- Unselfishness
- Unworthiness
- Useless
- Value
- Values
- Victims
- Victory
- Virtual reality
- Virtue
- Vision
- Visionary
- Volunteers
- War
- Warning
- Warning marker
- Wasted Opportunity
- Watchfulness
- Way to God
- Weakness
- wealth
- Weeping
- Wellbeing
- Wickedness
- Willfullness
- Winchester Mystery House
- Winners
- Winning
- Wisdom
- Witness
- Wonder
- Work
- Works
- World Wide Web
- Worry
- Worship
Meta
What a strange thing to say. Well, it’s a girl, so we don’t expect wisdom: Of course we can scan the brain and see the activity there and yes, we can also see that way that certain types of mental processes produce activity in certain parts of the brain. By doing that with thousands of people, we have a least some pretty good indication that the brain activity, commonly called “thoughts” do exist.
But, sorry, I am not amused by yet another sad attempt of a Christian to redefine a word to fit his personal beliefs (after “love”, “persecution”, etc. now we get “evidence”?). A simple look around the various religions of the world shows you, that the things people believe to “just know” vary wildly (and contradict each other). You are only trying to magically transform your personal belief into evidence. It just doesn’t work that way.
Good point, Atomic A; the range of things that people ‘just believe’ is huge and often contradictory. However my point is similar to what you say in your first paragraph: that our belief in the existence of things like human thought is based on personal experience rather than proved by actually seeing ‘thought’. Faith in a higher power behind the known universe is the same; observe many thousands of people and you see that there is actually something there.
Faith, like thought, can be used for good or evil; but it’s there.
A CAT scan will neither prove nor disprove that I have thoughts – nor will anything else based on the 5 senses; but I know that I think. In the same way tangible evidence via the 5 senses can neither prove nor disprove the reality of faith in God; but I know my faith is real. Much of what we know comes to us intuitively.
No, it is not even remotely the same. Brain activity, we can measure. We have examples of changes in personality after brain damage. We have tests on the influence of drugs, etc.etc.etc. We have various pieces of evidence, independent of personal bias (because that’s what good scientific studies do – remove as much human error as possible). And if you understood science, you would understand, that it’s not about proof – it’s about evidence.
On the other hand, we have your personal feeling.
No, sorry to burst your bubble here, but these two things are not the same. One is blind faith. The other is not.
And as much of what comes to us intuitively is, sorry, complete bullshit, I do not consider that a valid form of knowledge. People intuitively believe nonsense like homeopathy – despite it being proven completely useless again and again and again. What do I trust more? The vague feelings of a bored housewife without any medical education or hard, cold studies? Well, guess…
I think we may have to agree to disagree on how much difference there is here, Atomic M. The sort of things you refer to which confirm what we already know inwardly – ie: that there is such a thing as thought – are also present as confirmations that there is validity to faith in God. Research constantly shows that people with faith score higher on a holistic wellbeing scale than people without faith For example, one of the leading social analysts in America today is Arthur Brooks, currently president of the American Enterprise Institute.
In his 2006 book “Who Really Cares,” he summarized scores of academic studies demonstrating that religious people give far more to charity — even to non-religious charities — than do the non-religious. They’re also more likely to volunteer to serve with such charities, as well as to assist family and friends, to donate blood, to give food or money to homeless people on the street, and even to return change mistakenly given to them by a cashier.
In his 2008 book, Gross National Happiness, he reports that religious people of all faiths are, on average, markedly happier than secularists, and this is true even when wealth, age and education are taken into account. In one major survey, 23 percent of secularists reported being “very happy” with their lives, versus 43 percent of religious respondents. Believers are a third more likely to express optimism about the future. Unbelievers are almost twice as likely as the religious to say, “I’m inclined to feel I’m a failure.”
This also is evidence that what I know intuitively within myself is a reality.